Mama's Must-Haves

Articles · Baby

Best breast pumps you can get through insurance

Some links here are affiliate links. If you buy through one, I earn a small commission and your price stays the same. How that works.

A woman holding a baby bottle and looking at it

For most moms, the best breast pump to get through insurance is the Spectra S1 or S2. It is a double electric pump that many plans cover in full, and it is known for being quiet and comfortable. If you pump at work every day, the S1 adds a battery so you are not tied to an outlet. If you want to pump hands-free on the go, ask your supplier about a wearable like the Willow Go or Elvie Stride, which may be covered or offered as a paid upgrade.

Which pumps you can get depends on your plan. A breast pump supplier checks your coverage and shows you the list. This post helps you pick from that list.

How to get a pump through insurance

Most US health plans must cover a breast pump under the Affordable Care Act. Grandfathered plans are the main exception. The easy way is to order through a durable medical equipment supplier.

  1. Fill out a short form with a supplier like Aeroflow Breastpumps. You need your due date and your insurance card.
  2. The supplier checks your plan and sends you a list of covered pumps.
  3. Pick your pump. You can often pay the difference to upgrade.
  4. The supplier gets the prescription from your doctor and ships the pump.

Babylist Health is another option that works with many insurance plans. If you have a Babylist registry, you can start there.

My full guide on how to get a free breast pump through insurance walks through every step, plus what plans often skip.

My top pick

Spectra S1 Plus is the one I would pick if my plan covered it. It is a double electric pump with a rechargeable battery, a night light, and settings you can adjust. It lets you adjust both speed and suction. The battery means you can pump in the car, in a chair across the room, or during a power outage.

The Spectra S2 Plus is the same pump without the battery. It plugs into the wall. It is a great choice if you will mostly pump at home, and it is covered by more plans in full.

Shop it: Spectra S1 Plus or Spectra S2 Plus

Best for pumping at work

Medela Pump in Style with MaxFlow is a classic work pump. It is small, it comes with a tote on some versions, and parts are easy to find at most big stores. That matters when you forget a valve at home.

Motif Luna Double Electric Breast Pump is another popular pick that many plans cover. A version with a battery is also sold.

Shop it: Medela Pump in Style or Motif Luna

Best wearable pumps

A wearable pump fits inside your bra with no long tubes to a machine. It lets you pump while you drive, chase a toddler, or sit in a meeting. Wearables are often a paid upgrade, so ask your supplier what your share would be.

Willow Go Wearable Breast Pump sits fully in the bra and collects milk in cups.

Elvie Stride uses cups in the bra with thin tubes to a small motor you clip on your waistband. It is a middle ground between a wearable and a regular pump.

Many moms use a wearable as a second pump, with a double electric pump as the main one. Some find that a wearable does not empty as well, so watch your supply and talk to a lactation consultant if it drops.

Shop it: Willow Go or Elvie Stride

Best low cost backup pumps

These are cheap enough to buy on your own, even if your plan covers something else.

Haakaa Silicone Breast Pump is a one-piece silicone cup. Many moms use it on one side to catch milk while the baby nurses on the other.

Medela Harmony Manual Breast Pump is a hand pump for the diaper bag. It needs no power and no charger.

Shop it: Haakaa or Medela Harmony

Breast pumps at a glance

Pump Type Best for
Spectra S1 Plus Double electric, battery Most moms, pumping anywhere
Spectra S2 Plus Double electric, plug-in Pumping at home
Medela Pump in Style Double electric Work, easy parts
Motif Luna Double electric Covered by many plans
Willow Go Wearable Hands-free on the go
Elvie Stride Hands-free with small motor Hands-free, lower cost upgrade
Haakaa Silicone manual Catching letdown

Get the flange size right

The flange is the funnel part that fits over your nipple. A flange that is too big or too small can hurt and can lower the milk you get. Most pumps come with one or two sizes. Many moms need a different size. Ask a lactation consultant to help you measure, or use the sizing guide from your pump’s maker.

Flange inserts are a cheap way to try a smaller size.

What insurance often does not cover

Plans tend to skip the extras that make pumping easier. These are good items for your registry:

Shop it: pumping bras, storage bags, cooler bags, or pump wipes

What I would skip

Buying a pump at full price before you check your insurance. Most plans cover one. Check first, then buy only the extras.

A used pump that is not made for more than one user. Many personal pumps are single-user devices. Hospital-grade rental pumps are the ones made to be shared. If you get a hand-me-down, buy new parts and check the maker’s guidance.

Paying for the priciest wearable as your only pump. If it does not suit your body, you are stuck. Start with the covered double electric pump, then add a wearable later if you need one.

Questions parents ask

What is the best breast pump covered by insurance?

It depends on your plan. Many moms pick the Spectra S1 or S2, which a lot of plans cover. A supplier will show you the exact list.

Can I get a wearable breast pump through insurance?

Sometimes. Some plans cover a wearable in full. Others let you pay the difference to upgrade from a standard pump.

When should I order my breast pump?

Start a couple of months before your due date. Some plans ship before birth and others wait. Your supplier will tell you when.

Is the Spectra S1 or S2 better?

They pump the same way. The S1 has a battery and the S2 plugs in. Pick the S1 if you will pump away from an outlet often.

Does insurance cover replacement pump parts?

Many plans cover parts and milk storage bags on a schedule. Your supplier can check and remind you.

More for new moms: best bottles for breastfed babies, postpartum must-haves for mom, not baby, hospital bag checklist, and baby registry checklist.