Articles · Baby
Best pacifiers and how to pick a size
Some links here are affiliate links. If you buy through one, I earn a small commission and your price stays the same. How that works.
The best pacifier for most newborns is the Philips Avent Soothie. It is one piece of soft silicone, it is easy to clean, and many hospitals hand them out. For older babies, the MAM Air is a good next step. Pick the size by your baby’s age, as printed on the package.
The truth is, babies pick their own pacifier. One baby loves a brand and the next one spits it out. So buy one or two of a few kinds before you stock up.
How to pick a pacifier size
Most brands size pacifiers by age. The ranges are printed on the box. A common setup looks like this:
- Newborn or 0 to 3 months for the first weeks.
- 0 to 6 months for young babies.
- 6 to 18 months once teeth and a bigger mouth come in.
- 18 months and up for toddlers, if you still use one.
Each brand sets its own ranges, so read the package. Move up a size when your baby reaches the next age range or the pacifier looks small in their mouth. A bigger shield also helps keep it from going too far into the mouth.
Safety basics
The American Academy of Pediatrics says offering a pacifier at nap and bedtime may lower the risk of SIDS. If you are breastfeeding, many experts suggest waiting until feeding is going well, often around 3 to 4 weeks. Ask your doctor or lactation consultant what fits your baby.
- Do not force it. If baby spits it out in sleep, you do not need to put it back.
- Do not tie a pacifier around the neck or to the crib.
- Use a pacifier clip only when you are awake and watching. Take it off for sleep.
- Check pacifiers often. Toss any with cracks, tears, or a sticky nipple.
- Never dip a pacifier in honey or sugar.
My top pick for newborns
Philips Avent Soothie. It is one solid piece of hospital-grade silicone, so there are no seams for gunk to hide in. The round nipple works for many newborns. It is cheap, so it is a low-risk first try. This is the one I would bring to the hospital.
Shop it: Philips Avent Soothie
Best for breastfed babies
MAM Start Newborn Pacifier has a soft nipple and a small, light shield for tiny faces. Parents of breastfed babies often say it does not get in the way.
Nanobebe Pacifier is light and curved to sit away from the nose. It is a good one to try if the round Soothie does not work.
Shop it: MAM Start Newborn, Nanobebe Pacifier
Best for older babies
MAM Air Pacifier has a large air-vent shield that lets skin breathe. It comes in sizes for older babies. It is easy to find in most stores, which helps when one goes missing.
Dr. Brown’s HappyPaci is one-piece silicone with a butterfly shape. It is a good step up from the Soothie.
Shop it: MAM Air, Dr. Brown’s HappyPaci
Best natural rubber pacifier
Natursutten Natural Rubber Pacifier is made from one piece of natural rubber. Some parents prefer it to silicone. Natural rubber wears faster, so check it often and replace it on time. Skip it if anyone in the house has a latex allergy.
Frigg Daisy Pacifier comes in silicone or latex and has cute shapes. It is a popular gift.
Shop it: Natursutten, Frigg Daisy
Best extras
Pacifier clip for the stroller, car seat, or grocery cart. It saves you from washing a pacifier off the floor ten times a day. Daytime only, with you watching.
Pacifier case for the diaper bag so a clean one is always ready. My diaper bag checklist has the rest.
Shop it: Pacifier clip, Pacifier case
Quick comparison
| Pick | Age range | Best for |
|---|---|---|
| Philips Avent Soothie | Newborn and up | First pacifier |
| MAM Start Newborn | 0 to 2 months | Small faces |
| Nanobebe | 0 to 3 months and up | Babies who reject round nipples |
| MAM Air | 0 to 6 months and up | Easy to replace |
| Dr. Brown’s HappyPaci | 0 to 6 months and up | One-piece silicone |
| Natursutten | Newborn and up | Natural rubber |
What I would skip
Pacifiers with stuffed animals attached. They are cute, and they help some babies find the pacifier. But a plush toy does not belong in the crib, so they are daytime only. Most families do fine without them.
Stocking up on one brand before baby arrives. Buy two or three kinds in small packs. Once you know what your baby likes, then buy more.
Pacifier wipes. Soap and warm water work. For the first weeks, many parents boil or steam pacifiers. Follow the package.
If you are building your list, add a few pacifier kinds to your Babylist registry so you can try them before you buy a big pack. For sore gums later on, see my teether guide.
Questions parents ask
When should I give my baby a pacifier?
You can offer one from birth. If you are breastfeeding, many experts suggest waiting until feeding is going well, often 3 to 4 weeks. Ask your doctor what fits your baby.
How often should I replace a pacifier?
Check it every day and replace it at the first sign of cracks, tears, or a sticky feel. Many brands say every one to two months. Follow your package.
Can a newborn use a 0 to 6 month pacifier?
Yes, if your newborn takes it. Some newborns do better with a smaller shield, like a newborn size. Try both if the first one does not stay in.
When should my child stop using a pacifier?
Many dentists and doctors suggest cutting back after the first birthday and stopping by around 2 to 4 years. Ask your child’s dentist or doctor what makes sense for your child.
How do I clean a pacifier?
Wash it with warm soapy water and rinse well. For newborns, many parents boil or steam it. Check the package for what the maker says.