Mama's Must-Haves

Articles · Gift ideas

Big sister and big brother gifts for when the new baby comes

Some links here are affiliate links. If you buy through one, I earn a small commission and your price stays the same. How that works.

An older sister kissing her newborn baby sister surrounded by flowers

The best big sister and big brother gifts help an older child feel seen and keep them busy while you care for the baby. My top pick is a Yoto Player or Yoto Mini, since a big sibling can start their own story while you feed the baby. A book about becoming a big sibling and a baby doll of their own are close behind. Below are ideas for before the birth, the hospital visit, and the first weeks home.

I have brought a new baby home to big siblings more than once. The first few weeks are a big change for them. Everyone coos over the baby. Visitors bring baby gifts. A small gift just for the big kid goes a long way.

The best gifts here do one of three things. They help the big kid understand what is coming, give them a job, or keep their hands busy when your hands are full.

My top pick

Yoto Player. A screen-free audio player that plays a story when a child pushes in a card. A big sibling can start a story alone while you nurse or rock the baby. We have had a Yoto at our house for a long time, and it is still in daily use. The Yoto Mini is smaller and works well for younger kids. Read my Yoto Player review to pick one.

Books about becoming a big sibling

I Am a Big Sister by Caroline Jayne Church. A sweet, simple book for toddlers about life with a new baby. There is also I Am a Big Brother.

Peter’s Chair by Ezra Jack Keats. Peter is upset when his old things get painted for the baby. Then he changes his mind. It helps kids name mixed feelings.

Hello in There! A Big Sister’s Book of Waiting by Jo Witek. A big sister waits for the baby during the pregnancy. It is good to read in the months before the birth.

Julius, the Baby of the World by Kevin Henkes. Lilly does not like her new baby brother at all, until someone else is mean to him. It is funny and honest for preschoolers.

For more help, see how to prepare your child for a new sibling.

Shop it: I Am a Big Sister, I Am a Big Brother, or Peter’s Chair.

A baby of their own

Melissa and Doug Mine to Love baby doll. A soft doll to feed, change, and rock. Big siblings copy what you do with the real baby. It gives them a way to help that is always safe.

Baby doll carrier. A little carrier so they can wear their baby like you wear yours. Kids love matching you. It is a sweet photo moment too.

Doll stroller. Big siblings push their baby while you push yours. It makes walks with two kids easier. Pick one that is low and stable for toddlers.

Shop it: the Mine to Love doll, a doll carrier, or a doll stroller.

Quiet toys for feeding time

Melissa and Doug Water Wow books. Fill the pen with water and colors show up. There is no mess, so you can hand it over from the couch. It works for toddlers and preschoolers.

Reusable sticker books. Stickers peel off and go back on many times. Kids make scenes while you feed the baby. Keep one by the nursing chair.

Magnetic dress-up dolls or play set. Pieces stick on a board, so nothing rolls away. It is quiet and keeps hands busy for a while.

A “big kid basket”. Fill a basket with these toys and only bring it out at feeding time. The toys stay special, and the big kid looks forward to it.

Shop it: Water Wow, a reusable sticker book, or a magnetic dress-up set.

Keepsakes and big kid pride

Big sister or big brother shirt. A shirt to wear at the hospital visit or in the first photos. Kids feel proud wearing their new title.

Big sibling photo frame. A frame for a photo of the big kid holding the baby. Put it in their room, not just the nursery.

Kids camera. For an older big sibling, a kid camera lets them take baby photos too. It gives them a fun job when visitors come.

Shop it: a big sibling shirt, a photo frame, or a kids camera.

The gift “from the baby”

Many families have the baby “bring” a gift to the big sibling at the first meeting. Wrap something small and say it is from the baby. A doll, a book, or a Yoto card all work. It is a small thing that starts the friendship on a happy note.

If you have a registry, you can add a big sibling gift to it. Babylist lets you add items from any store. Start a free Babylist registry or add one to the registry you already have.

What I would skip

  • A big new toy the week the baby comes. Anything that needs your help to set up or play will not get that help. Save it for a few weeks later.
  • Lots of small-piece toys if the baby will crawl soon. LEGO and beads are great for big kids. But they need a plan to stay off the floor once the baby moves.
  • Too much “big sibling” gear. One shirt and one book are enough. A pile of big sister items can make the change feel even bigger.

Quick comparison

Pick Ages Best for
Yoto Player or Mini Toddlers and up Feeding time
I Am a Big Sister or Brother Toddlers Before the birth
Peter’s Chair Preschool Mixed feelings
Mine to Love doll Toddlers and preschool Copying you
Water Wow Toddlers and preschool Quiet, no mess
Kids camera School age A fun job

Questions parents ask

Should the new baby give the big sibling a gift?

Many families do it. A small wrapped gift “from the baby” at the first meeting can help the big sibling feel welcome. Keep it simple.

What do you get a toddler when a new baby is born?

A baby doll, a Water Wow book, a book about new babies, or a Yoto Mini. Toys they can use alone while you feed the baby help the most.

When should I give the big sibling gift?

Some families give it at the hospital or the first meeting at home. Others give a book in the months before. Both work.

How do I help my toddler adjust to a new baby?

Keep their routine the same when you can. Give them small jobs, like bringing a diaper. Spend a few minutes alone with them each day.

Planning for two? See second baby must-haves and what you can skip. Packing up? Here is my hospital bag checklist. Not sure what to buy? Try my gift finder quiz.