Mama's Must-Haves

Articles · Celebrations

Toddler Halloween costumes they will keep on

Some links here are affiliate links. If you buy through one, I earn a small commission and your price stays the same. How that works.

A young child wearing a bat wings costume

The toddler costumes that stay on are the ones that feel like regular clothes. My top pick is a costume hoodie, like a dinosaur, a bear, or a dragon, with matching sweatpants. A toddler can run in it, sit in it, and use the potty in it. Costume pajamas and simple two-piece sets come next. Masks, stiff hats, and scratchy tulle are the things toddlers pull off first.

I have watched a lot of toddlers in a lot of costumes at this point. The pattern is always the same. If it itches, pinches, or covers their head, it comes off before the second house.

Rules for a costume a toddler will wear

  • Soft fabric. Cotton, fleece, or jersey. Rub it on the inside of your wrist. If it scratches you, it will scratch them.
  • Nothing on the head that they did not pick. A hood attached to the costume is fine. A separate hat is a gamble.
  • Two pieces for potty training kids. A one-piece jumpsuit means a full undress at every bathroom stop.
  • Their own shoes. Costume shoes rub. Wear the sneakers or boots they already walk in.
  • Practice. Let them wear it around the house for a few days before Halloween.

My top pick: a costume hoodie

A toddler dinosaur hoodie with soft spikes down the back is the one I would buy. It looks like a costume from behind and feels like a sweatshirt. Pair it with green or gray sweatpants. The hood can come down if they hate it, and the costume still works.

The same idea works with a bear ears hoodie, a dragon hoodie, or a unicorn hoodie. They get worn all winter after.

Shop it: dinosaur hoodie, bear hoodie, dragon hoodie, or unicorn hoodie.

Best costume pajamas

Pajama costumes are soft by design, so toddlers do not fight them.

Skeleton pajamas that glow in the dark. Two-piece sets are easy for potty breaks. The glow helps drivers see a small kid.

Fleece animal onesie. A fox, a cat, or a penguin. Warm on a cold night. Best for kids still in diapers.

Pumpkin pajamas. Orange sets with a jack-o-lantern face. Add a green beanie for the stem.

Shop it: skeleton pajamas, fleece animal onesie, or pumpkin pajamas.

Best for toddlers who love a job

Some toddlers want to be what they see every day. These costumes go over regular clothes.

Firefighter costume. A jacket and a soft hat. If the hat comes off, the jacket still does the job.

Construction worker vest. A reflective vest is a costume and a safety tool. Add a toy hard hat if they want it.

Doctor or vet coat. A lab coat over a sweater, plus a toy stethoscope. A stuffed animal “patient” keeps hands busy.

Shop it: firefighter costume, construction vest, or doctor coat.

Best for toddlers who love to twirl

A dress-style costume works if the fabric next to the skin is soft.

Ladybug dress. Look for a cotton lining. Leggings underneath keep legs warm.

Witch dress with a soft hat. Pick a felt hat, not a stiff one. Many toddlers carry the hat instead of wearing it, and that is fine.

Bat wings. Fabric wings that attach at the wrists and back go over any black outfit. Easy on, easy off.

Shop it: ladybug dress, witch costume, or bat wings.

Quick comparison

Pick Age range Best for
Costume hoodie 18 months to 5 Kids who hate costumes
Skeleton pajamas 12 months to 5 Potty training
Fleece onesie 12 months to 3 Cold nights, diapers
Firefighter jacket 2 to 5 Kids who love trucks
Bat wings 2 to 5 Quick add-on

What I would skip

Masks of any kind. Toddlers cannot see well in them, and they come off right away. Face paint, a hood, or a nose dot with eyeliner gives the same look.

Polyester costumes with no lining. The cheap printed ones in a plastic bag tend to be thin, scratchy, and cold. A hoodie in the same theme costs about the same and lasts longer.

Character shoes and boots. Costume boots slide around and rub at the heel. Your toddler’s own shoes are better. If they need new ones, my post on toddler Doc Martens covers a pair that works with almost any costume.

How to get a toddler to wear it

Let them pick between two options you already like. A toddler who chose the costume is more likely to wear it.

Do a test run. Have a costume dinner or a living room parade a few days before. If something bugs them, you have time to fix it.

Keep the night short. Thirty minutes of trick-or-treating is plenty for most toddlers. Bring a plain hoodie in the stroller in case the costume has to come off.

For safety, add reflective tape and a glow stick bracelet, and hold hands near the road. See more of what I picked on my LTK shop.

If you have more than one little one, my sibling costumes post has themes for pairs and trios. If your Halloween is cold, see costumes that fit over a snowsuit. For the rest of October, my activities for toddlers post has easy ideas.

Questions parents ask

How do I get my toddler to keep their costume on?

Pick soft clothes they already like the feel of, skip hats and masks, and let them wear it at home first. A costume hoodie is the easiest win.

What is a good costume for a toddler who hates costumes?

A hoodie with ears or spikes and matching sweatpants. It feels like a regular outfit, so most toddlers do not notice they are in costume.

Are one-piece costumes bad for potty training?

They are hard. Your child has to take off the whole thing for every bathroom stop. Pick a two-piece costume during potty training.

Should toddlers wear face paint?

Face paint is fine if you test a small spot on the arm first. Use paint made for skin and wash it off before bed.

How long should a toddler trick-or-treat?

About 30 minutes is plenty for most toddlers. Go early, while it is still light out.