Mama's Must-Haves

Articles · Lifestyle

Yumbox vs Bentgo: which kids lunch box lasts

Some links here are affiliate links. If you buy through one, I earn a small commission and your price stays the same. How that works.

A blue Yumbox Original packed with crackers, cheese, rice cakes, cookies, and eggs

Yumbox and Bentgo are the two bento lunch boxes every parent ends up choosing between. They look alike in photos. They are not the same box. We have used both in this house, and I am happy with both. So this comes from real lunches, not a spec sheet.

Short version: Yumbox if your kid eats yogurt and dips and you want one lid that seals everything. Bentgo Kids if your kid is three to seven, eats small portions, and you want the cheaper box. Both beat a bag of loose containers.

The boxes

Bentgo Kids, OmieBox, LunchBots, and Yumbox lunch boxes in their packaging on a wood floor

The Yumbox Original has six compartments in a removable tray. One silicone-lined lid seals all of them at once when you close the latch. It is leakproof between compartments, so yogurt in one section stays out of the crackers in the next.

The Yumbox Panino is the same box with four compartments, one of them big enough for a sandwich. It is the one most school-age kids end up with.

The Bentgo Kids has five compartments in a removable tray, a leakproof lid, and a latch on each side. Bentgo sizes it for ages three to seven.

A Bentgo Kids lunch box with a dinosaur print lid beside its box and manual

The Bentgo Kids Chill adds a built-in ice pack under the tray, which saves you buying and losing a separate one.

Shop it: Yumbox Original, Yumbox Panino, or Bentgo Kids.

The seal

This is the whole reason to buy a bento box. Both are built so wet food in one compartment stays there.

The Yumbox lid has one silicone seal that presses down on every wall of the tray. It holds applesauce, yogurt, and hummus without a leak, as long as the latch is fully closed and the box rides upright. Store it on its side in a full backpack and you can get seepage. That is true of both brands.

Bentgo Kids uses a similar lid-and-tray design with two latches. Same rule: fine upright, not a submarine.

Tie. Both do the job if the box stays upright.

The compartments

Yumbox Original gives you six small sections. That is great for a grazer who wants a bit of everything and less great for a sandwich.

Yumbox Panino gives you four, with one big section. Sandwich kids want this one.

Bentgo Kids gives you five, portioned for a small appetite. Reviews from parents of older kids say it runs out of room. Bentgo makes bigger boxes for older kids, so size up if yours eats like a teenager.

Edge to Yumbox for choice. Edge to Bentgo if you want portions decided for you.

The latch

A lunch box a kid cannot open is a lunch box that comes home full. Young kids open the Yumbox latch alone. Bentgo’s two side latches are also made for small hands. Either is fine. A teacher will not be prying it open.

Cleaning

Both trays lift out. Both are listed as top-rack dishwasher safe. Hand washing keeps the colors brighter, and the silicone seal comes off the Yumbox lid for a wash every few weeks. Bentgo’s lid gasket needs the same attention. Skip that step with either brand and you will find something growing.

Tie.

How long they last

Our Yumbox has been through more than one school year and it still seals. The latch is the part that wears first on any bento box. Yumbox sells replacement trays and lids, so a broken part does not mean a new box.

Our Bentgo has done the job for us. Bentgo sells replacement trays and seals, the same as Yumbox.

Tie.

The price question

Bentgo Kids usually costs less than a Yumbox. I will not quote numbers because they move, but it is a real gap. If you have three kids to outfit, that gap adds up.

My take: pay for the Yumbox for the kid who eats wet foods and will use it for years. Buy the Bentgo for a preschooler who will outgrow the portion size anyway.

What to buy with it

A lunch bag that fits. Measure the box. Yumbox and Bentgo both sell bags cut to fit.

A slim ice pack. Unless you buy the Chill, which has one built in.

Silicone cups. Handy for splitting a big compartment or holding a dip.

A small thermos for soup days. Neither box keeps food warm.

Shop it: kids bento lunch bag, slim ice pack, or a Thermos food jar.

For packing ideas, see my Yumbox review and snack storage ideas.

This year’s codes and sales are on my Christmas deals page. Every guide is on the gift guides page.