Articles · Celebrations
Easter egg fillers that are not candy
Some links here are affiliate links. If you buy through one, I earn a small commission and your price stays the same. How that works.
The best non-candy Easter egg fillers are small, cheap, and fun to open. My top pick is stickers, because they fit in any egg, work for every age from 2 up, and are cheap in bulk. Mini playdough, coins, temporary tattoos, and little coupons for family treats are close behind.
Filling 30 eggs with candy adds up fast, and so does the sugar. Non-candy fillers last longer than a jelly bean. A lot of them are also easier for kids with food allergies, so every kid at the hunt can join in.
One thing first. Most egg fillers are small. Small things are a choking risk for kids under 3. I have a separate list for toddlers below.
Easter Sunday 2027 is March 28.
If you only buy one
A bulk pack of stickers. Fold a small sheet in half and it fits in an egg. Kids of every age like them. Kikkerland’s puffy animal stickers are a cute upgrade for a few special eggs.
For toddlers (1 to 3)
For this age, use the big eggs and fill them with things too large to choke on. Or leave them empty. Toddlers love opening eggs even with nothing inside.
Jumbo plastic eggs. Big enough to hold a board book page or a small plush.
Mini board books. Some sets have books small enough to fit in a jumbo egg.
Finger puppets. Soft and too big to swallow. Check the age label.
Puffs or a favorite snack. If they eat puffs, a few in an egg is a happy surprise.
Large stickers. Big shapes are easier for little fingers to peel.
Shop it: jumbo eggs, finger puppets, or big toddler stickers.
For preschoolers (3 to 5)
Mini playdough. The tiny tubs fit in a standard egg. Or make your own with my homemade playdough recipe and pack small balls in plastic wrap.
Temporary tattoos. Bunnies, chicks, and flowers. They will want one on right away.
Bubble wands. The mini party size fits in a large egg.
Mini cars. Small pull-back cars fit in a standard egg and get raced down the hall all day.
Crayons. Two or three mini crayons per egg. Add a coloring page to the basket.
Shop it: mini playdough, Easter tattoos, or mini cars.
For big kids (6 to 9)
Coins and a piggy bank. Quarters and loonies (if you are in Canada like me) are a hit. Put one golden egg with a bigger bill for the lucky finder.
Slap bracelets or friendship bracelets. Cheap, colorful, and easy to share.
Mini erasers. Shaped like animals or food. Kids collect and trade them.
Mini puzzles or brain teasers. A small metal or wooden puzzle keeps hands busy in the car.
Pocket kites. Kikkerland’s folded kite fits in a jumbo egg and flies on a windy day.
Shop it: slap bracelets, animal erasers, or Kikkerland’s pocket kites.
For tweens and teens
Cash. Roll up a few bills. Older kids will hunt for money long after they stop hunting for jelly beans.
Gift cards. A small card to a coffee shop or app store fits in a large egg.
Lip balm. A tube fits in a standard egg.
Hair ties and clips. Small claw clips are popular and cheap in packs.
Phone stickers. Waterproof vinyl stickers for water bottles and laptops.
Shop it: lip balm, claw clips, or vinyl stickers. More teen ideas are in my Easter basket ideas for tweens and teens post.
Free fillers: coupons and clues
Some of the best fillers cost nothing. Write these on small slips of paper and roll them up:
- Stay up 15 minutes late
- Pick what is for dinner
- A trip for ice cream with Mom
- Skip one chore
- Pick the family movie
- A clue to where the big basket is hidden
Clues are fun for big kids. Number the eggs, and each clue leads to the next spot.
Egg fillers at a glance
| Filler | Age range | Fits in |
|---|---|---|
| Large stickers | 1 and up | Any egg |
| Finger puppets | 1 to 3 | Jumbo egg |
| Mini playdough | 3 and up | Standard egg |
| Temporary tattoos | 3 and up | Any egg |
| Mini cars | 3 and up | Standard egg |
| Coins | 4 and up | Any egg |
| Slap bracelets | 6 and up | Standard egg |
| Cash or gift card | 10 and up | Large egg |
Safety tips
- Keep anything small enough to fit through a toilet paper tube away from kids under 3. That includes coins, erasers, and mini cars.
- Use a different egg color for toddlers. Fill those with only big, safe items. Tell the older kids to leave them.
- Count your eggs before you hide them. A forgotten egg with food in it can attract ants. A forgotten egg with a coin in it can end up in the baby’s mouth.
- Skip balloons. Popped balloon pieces are a serious choking risk for young kids.
What I would skip
Dollar store toys that break when you open them. Small plastic rings and whistles end up in the trash by lunch.
Slime in eggs. It leaks. If it gets on the carpet, my post on getting slime out of carpet will help, but it is easier to skip it.
Glitter anything. You will find it in June.
Questions parents ask
What can I put in Easter eggs besides candy?
Stickers, temporary tattoos, mini playdough, coins, bubbles, erasers, small cars, hair clips, and coupons for family treats.
How many eggs per kid for an Easter hunt?
Many families aim for 10 to 15 eggs per child. For a big group, set a limit so every kid finds the same number.
What can I put in plastic eggs for a 1 year old?
Use jumbo eggs with large, safe items like finger puppets, big stickers, or a few puffs. Or leave them empty. One year olds love opening and closing them.
Are non-candy Easter eggs good for kids with allergies?
Yes. Non-food fillers let kids with food allergies join the hunt. Check with parents before adding any snacks.
For more Easter ideas, see my Easter egg hunt ideas for toddlers and little kids, my Easter basket ideas by age, or my Valentine’s gifts for kids that are not candy. For Halloween, there is Halloween treats that are not candy. Need more ideas? Try the gift finder quiz.