Articles · Activities
Homemade playdough recipe with cream of tartar
Cooked playdough with cream of tartar is the recipe I recommend. It stays soft, it stretches, and it uses ingredients from the baking shelf. This post covers the exact amounts, the method, how to add color, how to fix a bad batch, and how to store it.
Ingredients
- 1 cup all-purpose flour
- 1/2 cup table salt
- 2 tablespoons cream of tartar
- 1 cup water
- 1 tablespoon cooking oil (vegetable or canola)
- Food coloring, 10 to 20 drops for a bright color
- Optional: 1 teaspoon vanilla extract for scent
Cream of tartar is the ingredient people skip. Please don't. It gives the dough its stretch and smooth feel. Without it, the dough turns out stickier and tears more easily. You will find it in the spice aisle of most grocery stores, next to the baking soda and vanilla.
Tools
You need a medium saucepan, a silicone spatula or wooden spoon, and a whisk. A non-stick pot makes cleanup easier because the dough sticks to the bottom as it thickens. You also need a clean counter or a sheet of parchment paper for kneading.
How to make it
Step 1: Mix the dry ingredients
Add the flour, salt, and cream of tartar to the saucepan. Whisk them together so there are no lumps. Do this before you turn on the heat.
Step 2: Add the wet ingredients
Pour in the water and oil. Add the food coloring and the vanilla now. Color mixed into the water spreads evenly through the dough, so you avoid streaks. Whisk until the batter is smooth. It will look like thin pancake batter.
Step 3: Cook on medium heat
Set the pot on medium heat. Stir without stopping. The batter will look lumpy first, then thicken fast. When it pulls away from the sides and forms one soft ball, it is done. This often takes a few minutes, but stove heat varies. Watch the dough, not the clock.
Step 4: Cool and knead
Turn the ball onto the counter or parchment. Let it cool for a few minutes until you can touch it comfortably. Then knead it for about a minute. The dough goes from slightly rough to smooth and soft. If it feels warm in the center, wait a little longer before you hand it to a child.
How to add color
I recommend gel food coloring over the liquid kind from the grocery store. Gel gives a deeper color with fewer drops, so the dough stays less wet. Liquid coloring works too. You may need more of it, and the colors come out softer.
You have two ways to make several colors.
- One batch per color. Add the coloring to the water before cooking. The color is even, and your hands stay clean. This takes more time, since each batch needs its own cook.
- One plain batch, split after cooking. Divide the cooled dough into balls. Press a hole in each ball, add a few drops of coloring, fold it closed, and knead. Wear disposable gloves. Food coloring stains skin for a day or so, and it stains countertops and clothes. If you need help, I have a post on getting stains out of clothes, and the same idea of treating the stain early applies.
To mix colors, knead two colors together until the swirl disappears. Red and yellow make orange. Blue and yellow make green. Red and blue make purple. Kids like watching this happen, and it works as a small color-mixing lesson.
Fix a bad batch
Most problems come down to too much water or too little. These fixes cover the common ones.
- Sticky dough. Knead in flour, one tablespoon at a time, until it stops sticking to your hands. If it is still wet in the middle, the dough was likely under-cooked. Return it to the pot and cook it a minute more on low heat.
- Crumbly or dry dough. Knead in a few drops of water or oil at a time. Wet your hands and keep kneading. Add liquid slowly, because it is easy to overshoot.
- Grainy dough. Salt that did not dissolve can cause this. Knead longer while the dough is still warm. Whisk the dry ingredients and water well next time.
- Dull color. Use gel coloring, or add more drops. Color deepens as you knead.
How to store it
Put the cooled dough in an airtight container or a zip-top bag. Press the air out of the bag before you seal it. Store each color in its own container, or the colors will bleed into each other. Keep the container at room temperature.
Check the dough before each use. Throw it out if it smells sour, feels slimy, or shows any mold. If the surface gets a little dry, knead in a few drops of water. Homemade dough has no preservatives, so it will not last as long as store-bought dough. I do not have a verified number of weeks to give you, and storage time depends on your kitchen, so rely on the smell and feel checks above.
Safety notes
This dough has a lot of salt. It is not food, and it is not meant to be eaten. Salty dough can also harm dogs if they eat it, so keep it off the floor and out of reach. Toddlers who still put everything in their mouths need an adult close by. The dough tastes bad, which usually stops a child after one try, but it is still a reason to stay close.
The dough also contains wheat flour. If your child has a wheat allergy or celiac disease, this recipe does not work, and the same goes for any child who plays near a sibling with that allergy. Check with your child's doctor about the right alternative.
Wash hands before and after play. Food coloring can cause a mess on hands, so a kid-sized apron helps.
Tools that make playdough more fun
You do not need to buy a playdough set. Use what you already have in the kitchen.
- A small rolling pin or a clean, empty bottle
- Cookie cutters
- Plastic knives and butter knives with rounded tips
- A garlic press for making spaghetti and hair
- Bottle caps, buttons, and beads for pressing patterns into the dough
- Dry pasta and craft sticks to poke into the dough
- A placemat or tray to keep the mess in one spot
Skip small items such as beads and buttons for any child who still puts things in their mouth.
Ways to play with it
Letters and numbers. Roll long snakes and shape them into letters. Press alphabet stamps into flat dough. Roll small balls and count them onto a number card. This pairs well with a free printable or a tracing sheet.
Sorting. Make dough in three colors. Ask your child to sort buttons or craft sticks by pressing each color into its matching ball. For more ideas in this style, see preschool sorting activities.
Fine motor work. Pinching, rolling, and squeezing dough builds the small hand muscles kids use for writing. Snipping dough with child-safe scissors also works.
Playdough mats. A mat gives a child a goal, such as building a face, shaping a letter, or filling in an outline. The store has printable playdough mats for $10 each. Print one, slide it into a plastic sleeve, and wipe it clean after play.
Rainy days. Playdough fills an hour when no one can go outside. For more indoor ideas, I wrote a list of rainy day activities for toddlers. If your child likes messy science, the oobleck recipe is the next kitchen project.
Quick answers
Can I use cream of tartar substitutes? Some recipes use lemon juice or white vinegar. I have not found a reliable amount that gives the same result, so I use cream of tartar.
Can I make it without cooking? No-cook versions exist. They often come out stickier and less stretchy than the cooked version. This post covers only the cooked recipe.
Can I double the recipe? Yes, but cook it in a larger pot and stir the whole time. A double batch takes longer to thicken, and the center can stay wet. Check for stickiness once it cools.
What oil works? Any plain cooking oil works. Baby oil is not needed.
Why does my dough feel greasy? You likely added too much oil. Knead in a spoonful of flour until it feels right.


