Mama's Must-Haves

Articles · Celebrations

Halloween treats that are not candy

Some links here are affiliate links. If you buy through one, I earn a small commission and your price stays the same. How that works.

Paper cutout bats, a pumpkin, and a trick or treat sign on a white table

The best Halloween treats that are not candy are small, cheap, and fun right away. My top pick is glow sticks, because kids use them on the walk home and they help drivers see trick-or-treaters. Stickers, pencils, mini playdough, bubbles, and temporary tattoos are close behind. Non-candy treats are also safe for kids with food allergies, which is why many families put out a teal pumpkin to show they have them.

A bowl of non-food treats also lasts. Whatever is left over goes into a stocking, a party bag, or the prize box. Nothing melts and nothing goes stale.

My top pick: glow sticks

Glow stick bracelets come in big packs, so they are cheap per kid. Kids snap them on right away, and a glowing wrist is easier for drivers to see. Hand them to the grown-up for toddlers, since little kids sometimes chew them.

Shop it: glow stick bracelets or glow necklaces.

Best for all ages

These work for toddlers through tweens.

Halloween stickers. Flat, light, and loved by every age. Sheets or rolls both work.

Mini playdough tubs. Small tubs are sold in Halloween packs. Kids under 2 need a grown-up nearby, since playdough is not food.

Bubbles. Tiny bottles with wands. They get used the next morning.

Temporary tattoos. Pumpkins, bats, and ghosts. They fit in any bag and weigh nothing.

Shop it: Halloween stickers, mini playdough, mini bubbles, or temporary tattoos.

Best for school-age kids

Kids 5 and up get more out of small school and play items.

Shop it: Halloween pencils, mini notebooks, slap bracelets, or fidget keychains.

Best for class parties

Class party bags need to be cheap per kid and safe for every child in the room. Ask the teacher about allergies and rules first.

A good bag holds three things: one sticker sheet, one pencil or eraser, and one small toy. For the toy, try mini pumpkin squishies, mini coloring books with a few crayons, or wind-up toys.

For something a little nicer, Kikkerland makes fun small gifts like wind-up toys and mini kits that work as party favors or a treat for your own kids.

Shop it: mini squishies, mini coloring books, wind-up toys, or Kikkerland.

Best eco-friendly options

If you want less plastic, pick treats that get used up or last.

  • Crayons in a small paper sleeve.
  • Seed packets for a spring garden.
  • Wooden toys like tops or yo-yos.
  • Paper treats like Halloween bookmarks or mini coloring pages.

EarthHero sells eco-friendly kids items and toys that work for this.

Shop it: EarthHero or Halloween crayon packs.

Quick comparison

Treat Age range Best for
Glow sticks 3 and up Trick-or-treat night
Stickers 2 and up Everyone
Mini playdough 2 and up Toddlers and preschoolers
Pencils and erasers 5 and up School-age kids
Slap bracelets 6 and up Grade school
Seed packets Any Eco-friendly homes

About the teal pumpkin

A teal pumpkin on the porch tells families you have non-food treats. It comes from the Teal Pumpkin Project from FARE, a food allergy group. It helps kids with food allergies, celiac disease, diabetes, or feeding tubes join in. You can paint a pumpkin teal, or print a sign for the door.

Keep the non-food treats in a separate bowl from any candy. That way a child with an allergy can pick freely.

Safety for little kids

Some small toys are choking hazards for children under 3. Skip these for toddler bags, or hand them only to older kids:

  • Bouncy balls
  • Spider rings and small plastic figures
  • Marbles and anything round and small
  • Balloons, which are a choking risk if they pop

Check the age label on every bulk pack. Most say “not for children under 3” if they have small parts.

How much to buy

Count the kids you saw last year, then add a few extra. If you are new to the street, ask a neighbor. A busy street can bring a lot of kids, while a rural road may bring only a handful.

Mix two or three kinds of treats in one bowl. Let each child pick one. Kids like choosing, and it stretches your supply.

Buy in early October. Halloween packs of stickers, glow sticks, and pencils sell out close to the date. Leftovers keep for next year, or go into party bags and stockings.

What I would skip

Tiny plastic toys in giant bulk packs. The 100-piece toy assortment looks like a deal, but much of it breaks or gets thrown out by morning. Fewer, better treats go further.

Fake vampire teeth. Kids put them in right away, they are a choking risk for small kids, and they get dropped on the sidewalk.

Toothbrushes. I know the idea. Kids are not excited, and parents already have them.

Questions parents ask

What can I give out for Halloween instead of candy?

Glow sticks, stickers, mini playdough, bubbles, temporary tattoos, pencils, and erasers are all good picks. Pick a few that suit the ages on your street.

What does a teal pumpkin mean?

It means you have non-food treats. The Teal Pumpkin Project helps kids with food allergies join trick-or-treating.

What non-candy treats are safe for toddlers?

Stickers, mini playdough with a grown-up nearby, and bubbles. Skip anything small and round.

Are glow sticks safe for kids?

They are fine for most kids with a grown-up around. The liquid inside can irritate skin and eyes, so watch toddlers who chew things. Call poison control if a child swallows the liquid.

What are good class party treats that are not food?

A sticker sheet, a pencil or eraser, and one small toy in each bag. Ask the teacher about class rules first.

For more ideas, see my Valentine’s gifts for kids that are not candy and stocking stuffers for toddlers. Spring is coming too, so bookmark Easter egg fillers that are not candy. For your own kids, my Halloween crafts for preschoolers post uses up leftover stickers.